On why taking OOL science seriously remains a challenge.

From CNN, Vapid Science News Headline of the Day: “Ingredients for Life Found” in Space Rocks
David Klinghoffer | @d_klinghoffer

Typical vapid science news headline of the day, from CNN: “Ingredients for life found in meteorites that crashed to Earth.”

Although two 4.5-billion-year-old meteorites crashed to Earth in 1998, it’s taken until now to uncover some of their secrets.

The two meteorites, called Monahans and Zag, are the first discovered to contain the ingredients for life: liquid water, amino acids, hydrocarbons and other organic matter.

A chemical-makeup analysis of blue and purple salt and potassium crystals from the meteorites was published in the journal Science Advances  on Wednesday.

Although it’s not exactly proof that life exists beyond Earth, the traces of water in the salt crystals could date to the earliest days of our solar system. The researchers compared it to finding a prehistoric fly preserved in amber.

The meteorites were found in Texas and Morocco.

“Not exactly proof” of extraterrestrial life, they say? It’s not a “proof” at all. It’s nothing like a “fly preserved in amber.” The “ingredients for life” are not the same thing as life, not any more than the English alphabet represents the “ingredients” for the next Great American Novel.

Don’t believe me? Here are those ingredients. You just have to multiply them a bit and get them in the right order:

ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ

Now go write the novel. You may submit it for our evaluation here and if you do, I might reconsider the claim that we’re anywhere closer today to understanding the origin of life than we were before these space rocks were closely studied.